Lee (2024)

Lee is a tepid biopic that features captivating performances by Andy Samberg and Kate Winslet. Cinematographer turned director Ellen Kuras tells the story of Lee Miller, a fashion model turned war photojournalist for Vogue magazine during World War II. While the story of Miller’s life was broad and detailed, the tale of such an influential woman’s story feels held back by the trappings of an unfocused script, genre clichés, and a general reluctance to delve deeper into what her work and her style did for women, journalism, and the world. 

The film opens with an interview from 1977. In proper standing with the conventional biopic – an older version of the protagonist is caked in prosthetics, reflecting on her life that the audience will soon relive through flashbacks. Interviewing this older version of Miller is an unnamed journalist, played by Josh O’Connor, struggling to get through to a woman whose cigarettes and drink are her best friends. She has a rigid scepticism about discussing her images’ impact on society. However, she proceeds to explain her past, beginning in pre-war France. 

Surrounded by wine and cheese, Lee spends her summers in Paris with friends, such as Pablo Picasso (Enrique Arce), Solange d’Ayen (Marion Cotillard), Paul Éluard (Vincente Colombe) and the man who eventually became her husband: artist Roland Penrose (Alexander Skarsgård). These are all Surrealists, featuring bohemian lifestyles where the women could chat at a picnic topless, and no one would blink an eye. Kuras captures Miller’s youth with a love for sex, drink, and, of course, pictures. It is a triangle of fun that all comes crashing down to reality once the war begins and The Blitz hits London. 

Knocking on the door of British Vogue editor Audrey Withers (Andrea Riseborough), Lee presents her portfolio and promptly promotes herself into a vocation that women at the time clambered to obtain – photojournalism. Once friends go missing, fascism spreads further, and Lee notices the gross mistreatment that women face from soldiers in times of war; her ambitious passions soon find her at the violent centre of the frontline. While Roland is off joining the Royal Engineers, Lee fights her way through bureaucracy and sexist army generals to achieve even a minimum of what her job requires.

Once the film reaches the war, particularly the Buchenwald and Dachau concentration camps, Winslet and the film begin to shine. Alongside Life magazine photographer David E. Scherman (Samberg), the two headstrong journalists capture some of the most provocative images during their pairing: stepping inside train cars and capturing piles full of dead bodies, young women hiding out of fear, and, of course, the famous image of Lee taking a bath inside Hitler’s tub. The film does an ample job of capturing both Miller and Scherman’s capability to record and actively participate in history.

One striking sequence features Vogue refusing to print images of the horrors Miller has captured, a particular standout in the film. It stresses her despair, drive, and compassion for the victims of war crimes that people either turned their heads from or were unaware of. The magazine wants people to move on from the war, but Lee makes educating and telling the world imperative to her values. Her forthright and committed attitude paved the way for some of the most crucial war photography in the 20th century – standing by idly would never ensure these images. When so invested in the injustice around her, Winslet gives the character a beautiful mix of empathy and frustration.

The unfortunate structure of the film builds off contrivance and padding, providing ‘gotcha’ reveals in a movie that doesn’t need them. Focusing on what the film wants to capture most, Lee’s effort on the frontline is far more compelling than the surrounding storylines before and after the war. Instead of keeping closer proximity, the screenplay by Marion Hume, John Collee, and Liz Hannah keeps the audience at a certain distance. Miller was an active member of the Surrealist movement, a complicated mother, an alcoholic, and a fashion model who went on to create her own style of photography – but the film touches only fragments of these life events. Sadly, many of these complexities that make up Lee are left elliptical and vague.

To say Kate Winslet has a deep adoration for Lee Miller is an understatement. She pours her heart into a role she’s been trying to play for over eight years—even paying the entire cast and crew salaries for two weeks when the funding got tight. Having also spent the whole press junket promoting the woman she is playing more so than the film itself, Winslet’s performance is rousing in ways that channel her respect for the real-life figure. The only occasional detraction in her performance is an American accent that feels a tad artificial.

The surprising standout, however, is Andy Samberg, who gives the film the highest sincerity and expressive weight. From the comedic heights of SNL and Brooklyn Nine-Nine, Samberg reminds us of all that comedic actors can do to switch dramatic gear successfully – providing effortless chemistry with Winslet and capturing the tender pain of a Jewish person who would document the genocide of his people.

Capturing the horrors of devastation is an all-too-present issue. Lee Miller had one camera—a tool now everyone has on their phone. Desensitivity to war, genocide, and violence, in concoction with disinformation, has become a frightening norm. One image in Vogue magazine doesn’t have the same impact now as a thousand daily on social media. Censorship on both forms, however, has, and will continue to happen. Lee fundamentally explores the need for courage, truth-telling, and confronting the evil that people can easily ignore. Especially from a woman whose opportunity to live this life was far slimmer than a man’s. 

Lee may not be the best film it could be, but it is still a practical reminder to remember and investigate women like Lee Miller. She was a trailblazer and an ambitious advocate for documenting history. Watching Alex Garland’s Civil War will make it easy to notice how much Miller inspired Kirsten Dunst’s character, Lee Smith. It is a shame that Kuras’ film couldn’t create an image as transgressive, influential, and daring as the woman it is based on. 

Author

Comments

Share this review
Andy Samberg, Ellen Kuras, holocaust, lee, Lee Miller, period drama, World War 2 film

Related Posts

No results found.