The Roses (2025)

The first screen adaptation of Warren Adler’s 1981 novel ‘The War of the Roses’ was Danny DeVito’s movie released in 1989 starring established “screen couple” Kathleen Turner and Michael Douglas as the scorched earth divorcing couple. Jay Roach’s The Roses remains a dark comedy involving a married couple whose caustic marriage breakdown takes them to extremes. The Roses avoids the remake curse by using the skeleton of Adler’s novel to allow screenwriter Tony McNamara’s trademark wit and wickedness to reinvent the Roses in the form of the delectable pairing of Olivia Colman and Benedict Cumberbatch.

Ivy (Colman) and Theo (Cumberbatch) are in couple’s therapy and after almost two decades of marriage. Their therapist tells them that she can only advise that they don’t have the capacity to fix their problems. They both laugh and dismiss the therapist as a quack despite the evidence that they indeed don’t have anything positive to say about each other beyond that Theo is glad he lives with Ivy rather than a wolf and that Ivy appreciates Theo has arms. “Theo, what a c*nt,” Ivy ends her list which sends Theo into a fit of giggles. “So much resentment. So much mockery!” the therapist marvels. “In Britain we call that repartee,” Theo says still laughing. “It’s terrible to think we almost lost each other,” and “Do you remember the day we met?” Theo and Ivy’s voices narrate. And with that the audience enters the couple’s past and future.

In London Theo is trying to avoid celebrating the completed plans for a building his architecture firm has designed with zero interest in the people who will live there. He escapes into the kitchen where he comes across junior chef, Ivy. Palpable attraction, immediate sex, and ten years later they’re living in Northern California with two great kids and Theo’s dream design for the East Bay Museum about to come to fruition. Ivy hasn’t made time for her career dreams, but she’s still an amazing and inventive cook. The Roses are blissfully happy.

Theo, confident his career is going to take off to the next level, realises Ivy has given up her career goals as a mother of two and puts money into a fix-it-up space for her to open a restaurant. Ivy opens ‘We’ve Got Crabs!’ which is at most doing thirty covers a week, which suits them both as she can cook and get stoned, and Theo can tick off the equality ledger. A freak storm changes their individual fortunes. Theo’s genius and unconventional sail design comes crashing down in a spectacular, filmed, and memed fashion. On the flip side, the storm closes off major roads and ‘We’ve Got Crabs!’ is not only filled with people, one of them is a food critic. Theo is humiliated and broken (also fired), and Ivy’s star is on the rise. It makes sense that they shift to Ivy bringing in the money and Theo bringing up their kids Hattie and Roy (played adorably by Delaney Quinn and Ollie Robinson). For a couple so previously solid and sure of their love for each other, the attrition of falling out of sync with each other begins to be who the Roses are. 

Theo channels his energies into bringing up the kids to favour discipline and success which alienates Ivy. Ivy becomes a wild-card culinary sensation who can’t forgive Theo for wallowing in his neediness and desire for approbation. Every time they attempt to reignite their relationship they dig deeper into a well of resentment and inability to connect. Within a few years they’ve become cruel and the banter they once had turns into direct insults that get more pointed and egregious. Hattie and Roy (Hala Finley and Wells Rappaport) get accepted at only thirteen to a school in Miami for elite athletes. Without the kids around Ivy and Theo realise they have nothing to hold on to in their own relationship. The dream house Ivy funds and Theo designs and builds is a tangible reminder of their brilliance and their failure to share in each other’s happiness. The house is the battleground where all is fair in war and… war.

While Colman and Cumberbatch have undeniable chemistry and deliver McNamara’s witty script with aplomb, the movie tends to underuse the supporting cast. Ncuti Gatwa and Sunita Mani as Ivy’s staff Jeffrey and Jane are fantastic when given their precious few lines. Andy Samberg is typically wonderful as the couple’s mutual friend Barry but Kate McKinnon as his wife Amy is screen poison in every painful scene she’s in. McKinnon, who has proven herself to be a great comedic talent over the years, is clumsy, heavy handed, and painfully unfunny. It’s hyperbolic to suggest that a supporting character is enough to ruin a movie, but McKinnon gives it a good college try. 

The Roses is a solid studio comedy buoyed by Colman and Cumberbatch who are brilliant as both lovers and enemies. However, the humour is on the whole is designed to appeal to audiences familiar with the cadences of British comedy over American and will perhaps struggle to connect with the latter. Some people may find it mean spirited because when The Roses becomes sincere it doesn’t quite hit with as much impact as requires. 

The Roses is satisfying and funny despite not hitting every mark it could for wide appeal. You’ll wonder why Colman and Cumberbatch haven’t been paired before as they are made to be on screen together trading quips and barbs and sharing a glorious and instinctual mutual rhythm. Deliciously destructive and delightfully dry — The Roses is bound to be a blast for many who crave seeing two actors at the top of their game playing game.

Author

Comments

Share this review
benedict cumberbatch, dramedy, Olivia Colman, roses, The Favourite, The War of the Roses, Tony McNamara, Warren Adler

Related Posts